Man From Plains
Posted in Freelance Reviews by adminMan From Plains: The Courage to Reinvent a Legacy
The Jonathan Demme (Oscar, Silence of the Lambs) documentary chronicles former President Jimmy Carter’s 2006 book tour, illustrating the reactions and perspectives that accompanied the release of “Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid.” The film confirms transformation of the Carter legacy, from the president who presided over a staggering economy to a genuine and committed statesman for global peace and diplomacy.
Produced by Neda Armian and starring Jimmy and Rosalynn Carter, both of whom attended the February 16th premiere at the Rylander Theatre in Americus, Georgia, “Man From Plains” is a snapshot into a progressive perspective on contemporary Middle Eastern politics. Carter’s thesis, that peace will forever elude Israel until they back away from the land that was awarded to Palestine after World War II, was predictably contested by much of the American media. However, with a balanced and confident approach, Carter holds true his convictions, in the process educating much of his audience. Interviews from CNN, PBS, NPR, the Los Angeles Times and The Tonight Show highlight his stops in the immediate days following the book’s release. Carter also speaks to an energized crowd at Brandies University, a predominately Jewish University. But the political discussions have the propensity to move from healthy dialogue to emotional charges of Antisemitism, chiefly from the connotations brought on by Carter’s word choice in the title.
Harvard law professor Alan Dershowitz offers to debate Carter in order to support his contention that the legally elected Palestinian majority, Hamas, should be treated with zero tolerance. However, the film is clear to point out that the Bush administration broke off all political ties with Hamas once they received a majority in the election, and that much of the U.S. stance is driven by the huge AIPAC (American Israeli Political Action Committee) congressional lobby. Dershowitz could have been dismissed as a fanatic himself (he publicly endorses the torture of Hamas supporters), but the filmmakers chose to allow him an evenhanded voice. Hamas, of course, currently endorses Jihad against all Jews, but only because Israel has built a wall around their already limited land, and imposed inhumane and oppressive policies that have led to starvation and isolation. Carter’s humanitarian approach maintains that if Israel gets out, peace will have a chance.
The former president’s stance is another indication that Christians can be politically progressive, a memo to a segment of our middle class base that continues to group anyone of the faith into the Huckabee progression. Carter reveals clearly in a clip from his weekly sermon at the Plains Baptist Church that while he remains true to his Christian beliefs, he is worldly enough to acknowledge the limitations of a literal translation of the Bible.
The film also works because it sprinkles in pieces of a private life that remains truthfully public, supporting the reality that the Carters are hardly kin with the existing political elite. Segments from Carter’s family farm in Plains, a scene where the former president sheds tears after hearing an intern address the Carter Center in Atlanta, and the unexpected way he used the concept of family to persuade Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin and Egypt President Anwar Sadat to sign the 1978 Camp David agreement depict an honorable and authentic heart.
Not since Eisenhower’s farewell speech that warned of the creation of the “military industrial complex” has a United States president stood up with this much courage to pay notice to a subject that needs debate. Indeed, Carter acknowledges that there is even a discussion of the Israeli policy towards Palestine in Israel, but the issue remains silenced in the United States. Ultimately, the viewer is reminded of the evolution of Carter’s legacy, and the dire need for global discourse in a crucial matter that directly influences United States foreign policy.
Further reading:
Petras, James, The Power of Israel in the United States, Clarity Press, Inc., 2006.
Carter, Jimmy, Palestine: Peace Not Aparthied, Simon & Schuster, 2006.